by Lenora Dannelke

From Wert’s Cafe

If eggs have aspirations, the highest and best use they might hope to attain is the mile-high—an exaggeration, sorry!—Lemon Meringue Pie at Wert’s Café, a homey dining destination since 1968. General Manager Kathy Drake (née Wert) attributes the recipe for this American classic to her maternal great-grandmother. Standing firmly by tradition, little more than lemons and sugar join yolks and whites in the creation of a vibrantly tart-and-sweet lemon filling piled with a lusciously light topping. A flaky golden-brown crust provides textural balance to the beloved pastry, and darkly toasted meringue peaks add striking visual appeal. 

It takes patience and a steady hand with a cake spatula for Barbara Weaver, house baker for the past 22 years, to pull the smooth mound of meringue into precise hedgehog-like “spikes” that bake to a deep brown. (Weaver likens the flavor of the peaks to fire-toasted marshmallows.) Although assorted baked goods are made fresh daily, Lemon Meringue Pie remains a Thursday feature—and both eat-in and take-out patrons often call to reserve a hefty slice. If sold out, find consolation in coconut custard pie, carrot cake, or the restaurant’s many other scrumptious sweets, including chocolate-frosted éclairs scratch-made every Friday. 

Wert’s Café

515 N 18th St, Allentown

As seen in the Winter/Spring 2021 Issue

Click to Visit Our Advertisers

Hager Furniture
American Fence
Warner Art and Glass
Richards Window Fashions
Roche Painting
Gail Gray
Carol Dorey
Paver Savers
Susan Bella Jewelry
Klingel's Farm